Customer Reviews:
Showing reviews 11-15 of 50
 Condescention Clash November 24, 2007
Thomas Severs (Wichita, KS United States)
8 out of 12 found this review helpful
Ms. Donaldson's book drips of condescension. For example, on page 61 she tells the reader to "pound this into your brain: dogs are animals."
If you think your dog is a person, and you need a pompous author to point this out to you over and over, this is your book.
If you are a dog lover who wants to develop healthy and fun behaviors between you and your dog, every other book out there is a better choice.
The best book on understanding a dog as an animal is "How to Speak Dog" by Stanley Coren. He will explain all the things the dogs ears say by their various postions, he will explain the meaning of head position, tail movement, etc. Mr Coren is respectful to both animals and to readers.
 A Masterpiece November 14, 2007
DENISE (West Lebanon, NH)
0 out of 2 found this review helpful
If I were going to buy only one dog training book this would be it. I especially liked the first chapter and the section on Planet Gorn (Chapter 4). I'm not comfortable using pain to train pet dogs, so I really appreciate her painless techniques and the way she goes beyond myths and examines the real science and evidence.
 Excellent intro to dogs November 2, 2007
germantownmom (Katy, TX USA)
2 out of 3 found this review helpful
There's a ton of great info in this book. The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is that it isn't as read-able as it should be to appeal to the general non-dog "fanatic" (I use that word in the best possible way, as I am a dog fanatic myself!) public. That said, I recommend it to everyone I know who is having trouble with their dog.
positive dog training October 9, 2007
Amy Michelle (Wilmington, NC)
1 out of 1 found this review helpful
Great book on positive dog training! It was a very fast read, very interesting and gave a lot of insight to how many people treat their dog and how people actually should treat their dogs. The book explained how people generally are interpreting what their dogs are thinking to mean the wrong thing, and how we actually should read those behaviors. There are a lot of examples throughout the book on ideas for training dogs, and then a chapter on basic behavioral training at the very end.
One of the best books on positive dog training September 20, 2007
Rise VanFleet, PhD (Pennsylvania)
8 out of 8 found this review helpful
I see lots of controversy in the reviews, but I think many of the negative reviewers have missed some important points in this volume, or perhaps have reacted emotionally to them. This is an excellent book on positive dog training - one of the best. If you want a close, mutually-respectful relationship with a well-behaved dog, this is really the way to go.
Jean Donaldson fully acknowledges that we can build close relationships with our animals and that the use of classical and operant conditioning are not the only methods that can be used for training. She simply shows that these approaches are the most effective ways, and the most scientifically-validated approaches for socializing and training dogs using positive methods. If you want to teach your dog good behavior or new behaviors, socialize it well and use positive behavior methods. You can still be emotionally close with your dog, but don't use your (or your dog's) emotions as the primary TRAINING tool--we all tend to respond more readily to consequences when we're learning. When applied properly, Donaldson's methods really do work with a very wide range of dogs and problems. Some reviewers may be unhappy because the currently-popular "pack theory" is not supported in this book. In my reading of it, however, I did not see Donaldson "slamming" pack theory, but merely stating that there's a lack of scientific evidence that it really works, and she offers a noncoercive method that DOES have solid science behind it. Through effective use of behavioral methods, as explained in this book, you can create a most satisfying relationship with your dog, and your dog will respect you. But at the same time, the training takes into account the unique characteristics of dogs. Dogs do not need to be subjugated in order to follow our leadership. (Actually, when you watch some of the "leader of the pack" trainers work, you'll also see them using a LOT of what Donaldson talks about. What Donaldson avoids are the aversive control measures that are sometimes employed by others.)
As a psychologist, I thought Donaldson's explanations of behavioral methods were very good, although they might be a bit technical or detailed for some. I train therapy dogs to work with children, and I also train children to interact positively with therapy dogs, and I really have no choice but to use positive methods. The kids learn how to be the leader for the dog, but we do it via all-positive methods, such as defined in this book.
I've trained a lot of dogs through the years using a variety of methods, and I've recently reviewed many training books in preparation for a book I've written about using dogs in play therapy, and I wholeheartedly endorse positive training methods as the means of training dogs for a wide range of roles: well-behaved pets, obedience, therapy work, and traditional working dogs (such as herding or hunting). Donaldson makes it clear how and why this works.
Some may want an easy manual of the "10 steps to training a dog," and this book is not organized that way. I think its aim is to educate the owner or trainer in a process, and how to apply that process to a wide range of situations and behaviors. Ultimately, understanding the material in this book permits owners/trainers much more versatility in the work they do with dogs.
I strongly recommend this book. To get the most out of it, put your preconceived notions on a back burner and really try to see what she is saying. She provides the most effective way of helping dogs learn our human ways (by requiring us to learn about their canine ways!), and ultimately, having a well-socialized and well-mannered dog can only deepen the loving relationships we have with our pets. We have 4 dogs (2 are rescues who came with some problems), and I'm as attached as ever to all of them, and a lot less frustrated when I'm trying to teach them something new!
|
